Ankle fractures are one of the more common injuries encountered by orthopaedic surgeons and can represent a significant burden in terms of morbidity. The primary concern with these injuries is the long-term risk of post-traumatic arthritis in the ankle. While there are controversies about both diagnosis and treatment for some of these injuries, ensuring the maintenance or restoration of normal anatomy can help to reduce the risk of arthritis.
The fibula and tibia come together to form the ankle mortise and articulate with the talus. The majority of the stability of the ankle with weight-bearing is conferred by the very congruent bony anatomy. However, ligaments play a role in stability as well, as the large deltoid ligament medially provides a broad connection between the medial malleolus and the talus. On the lateral side the tibio-fibular articulation, or syndesmosis, is stabilized by the anterior and posterior inferior tibio-fibular ligaments (AITFL and PITFL respectively), as well as the interosseous ligament and, to a lesser degree, the interosseous membrane extending proximally. These syndesmotic ligaments can be injured in some ankle fractures.
Ankle fractures as they are traditionally classified by Lauge-Hansen fall into a couple of different categories.
- Supination-external rotation (SER) fractures represent the majority of these injuries, with the supination describing the position of the foot and external rotation the applied force. In this scenario, however, it is the foot that typically remains planted while the leg internally rotates relative to the foot. The injury will often proceed in a progressive manner in which injury begins anteriorly and then proceeds clockwise around the ankle.
- Pronation-external rotation (PER) fractures typically begin medially and then proceed clockwise with a primary difference being that the syndesmosis is often disrupted and the fibula fracture is often a Weber C, “high” fibula fracture. Both of these fractures will often have some degree of posterior malleolus fracture in which the intact posterior-inferior tibiofibular ligament (PITFL) pulls off a piece of bone.
- Supination adduction (SAD) fractures and pronation abduction (PAB) fractures are injuries that typically proceed just in the coronal plane and do not involve rotation.
- SAD fractures proceed from lateral to medial and start with a low fibula fracture and then the talus can be driven into the medial shoulder of the plafond, creating a characteristic vertical medial malleolar fracture that can often have articular impaction.
- PAB fractures proceed from medial to lateral with fracture of the medial malleolus and then often a characteristic “high” fibula fracture with comminution. The rotational fractures and PAB injuries can also injure the syndesmosis with those injuries that have “high” fibula fractures being perhaps more likely to have syndesmotic disruption. The rotational fractures, and indeed any of these fractures, can also be influenced by the relative plantarflexion of the ankle. Posterior pilon variants in which there is some degree of posterior comminution have been described. These fractures can extend more medial or have an entirely separate posteromedial piece than the typical posterior malleolus fracture that is posterolateral.
Ankle fractures represent a broad spectrum of injury and fitting that into a single clinical presentation is not possible. That being said, patients will typically have swelling, bruising, and global pain about the ankle. Swelling will often not reach its zenith until about 72 hours after injury.
Decision for Surgery
The goal of ankle surgery is restoration of normal anatomy if possible. Approximately 70% of people with ankle arthritis have a history of significant ankle injury. This risk is thought to be related to two things: the impaction at the time of the injury and the possibility of malunion leading to uneven articular loading. The impaction at the time of the injury is a function of the injury itself and cannot be changed with or without surgery. Malunion, however, can often be avoided by fixing the injury surgically. However, we do not operate on all ankle fractures. Ultimately, the decision comes down to whether the injury is felt to have sufficient instability that there is risk of any displacement with treatment by closed means.
From a practical standpoint most bimalleolar and trimalleolar fractures are unstable, and, therefore, will benefit from surgical treatment. Rarely, patients will have these injuries (i.e. bimalleolar or trimalleolar fractures) that do not show any displacement, and these injuries can be treated nonoperatively.
Once the decision for surgery is made, treatment most often consists of fixing the bony injuries. In a fibula fracture with deltoid ligament insufficiency, the fibula alone is often all that is fixed, providing a lateral buttress to hold the talus underneath the plafond. Repair of the deltoid ligament during the same surgery is controversial. In a bimalleolar fracture most surgeons will fix both the medial and lateral malleoli. In a trimalleolar fracture the medial and lateral malleoli will also be fixed, but fixation of the posterior malleolus is controversial as above. If a syndesmotic injury is present, screws or strong suture that hold the tibia and fibula together, are often required. However, as above, these screws may be obviated if the PITFL can be reestablished.
Post-operative treatment typically involves a period of non-weight-bearing, with a majority of surgeons favoring at least 6 weeks, although there is little consensus about what time period is most appropriate. With syndesmotic injury the time period is often extended to some degree. Once the patient is removed from the post-operative splint and prior to weightbearing, the patient is allowed to work on ROM exercises, which help provide the cartilage with nutrition and can potentially decrease intraarticular scar tissue.
Written by J. Turner Vosseller, MD Reviewed by F. Ray Nickel, MD Last reviewed July 2015